|

By
Dr.
Gamal Abou Al-Serour
FRCOG, FRCS
Professor
of Obstetrics and Gynaecology
Director
of the International Islamic Center
for
Population Studies and Research,
Al-Azhar
University
&
Clinical
Director of the Egyptian IVF & ET Center,
Maadi,
Cairo, Egypt
Member
of the FIGO Ethics Committee
Published
by
Islamic
Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization
-ISESCO-
1421 A.H. / 2000 A.D. |
|
INTRODUCTION
Since the birth of the first child to be born as a result of In-Vitro fertilization and
embryo transfer (IVF/ET) Louise Brown by Steptoe and Edwards in England in 1978(1),
there has been an extensive ethical debate on the technique all over the world. As the
procedure could be replicated in so many centers all over the world specially in Muslim
countries(2, 3, 4), societies have recognized that human embryos had
become available to the hands of scientists in the IVF-ET laboratories widely distributed
today in almost every country in the world. This availability of human embryos in the
laboratories made human embryo research an existing reality in the scientific research
field.
As much as human embryo research created scientific interest to those involved in this field,
it invited a greater interest and concern by the public. This is certainly due to the fact
that although human embryo research is a purely scientific development, yet it involves
human reproduction and transfer of genetic material. Consequently, every member of the
society feels that he/she is concerned with what happens of progress in this field. Many
societies even feel that they are not only concerned with what happens in this field, but
they ought to monitor, watch carefully, regulate and even sometimes restrict or totally ban
such development. The reasons for such reactions could be attributed to the fear of many
socieities that the glory of scientific achievements and progress could very well be a
driving force to some scientists in some parts of the world to use the available embryos for
uncontrolled research projects. In the absence of very tight ethical regulations, the
ethical values of the societies may be violated for the sake of scientific achievement. No
doubt the reaction of different societies differs according to the social, cultural,
religious, philosophical and political background of each society. It would, therefore, be
appropriate to discuss, in a document, ethical issues involved in human embryo research from
an Islamic perspective to include a brief background on how rulings are derived in Islamic
Sharia on matters not mentioned in its primary sources namely the Holy Quran and Sunna. It
would also be appropriate to briefly discuss the basis of formulation of ethical arguments
in the Western Societies on matters which evolve as a result of scientific development and
innovation. These two backgrounds would certainly help the reader to understand the stance
of Muslims from such scientific innovations. No doubt Muslims are for the progress of
scientific development for the benefit of humanity. However, these scientific development
must follow certain guidelines which ensure that the human being whether at an individual
level or at national and international level would not come to harm or suffer unforeseen
risks from these development. Science without control ruins the soul.
|